Western Medicine

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is a chronic, inflammatory disorder of connective tissue that usually arises without obvious cause and is regarded as an autoimmune disease. It affects many different organ systems of the body and varies in severity between patients and, over time, within the same patient.
Typical features of SLE are a symmetrical red rash to the face, arthritis and progressive damage to the kidneys.

Chinese Medicine

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is an autoimmune disease that can affect the joints and many organs of the body, commonly the skin and kidneys. The disease course can range from mildly episodic to severe, and can be fatal. Symptoms vary from individual to individual and are characterized by remission and exacerbation. The complex presentation of the disease can make diagnosis difficult.
No definitive term exists for SLE in the ancient Chinese medical classics. Individuals are diagnosed with different syndromes according to the presentation of symptoms and are treated according to the disharmony patterns displayed under these syndromes.

• Symptoms of fever and skin rash are diagnosed as yin-yang poisoning, Prurigo, itching dermatitis of the face, cheek sores and solar dermatitis syndromes.
• Joint pain, muscle pain and Raynaud's phenomenon are classified as bi-syndrome.
• Heart involvement, causing symptoms of palpitations and shortness of breath, is referred to as palpitation syndrome.
• Nervous system symptoms are grouped as hysteria syndrome.
• Symptoms resulting from multiple asthenia syndromeorgan systems involvement are classified as . This can then lead to consumptive disease.
• Kidney involvement is defined as kidney deficiency.

The kidneys are very important in TCM and are considered (as in Western medicine) to be commonly involved in SLE.

As SLE is a disease that can affect the whole body and involve several organs, different syndromes or disharmony patterns may occur at the same time and present a multiplicity of symptoms.

Western Medicine

SLE can occur at any age, but most often arises between the ages of 16 and 55 years. It occurs more frequently in women. In children, the female to male ratio is 4:1; in adults, it ranges from 8:1 to 13:1; and in older individuals, the ratio is 2:1. The highest frequencies and severity are in women of Afro-Caribbean, Chinese, Asian and South American Indian ancestry.

SLE occurs with greatest frequency and severity in women of Afro-Caribbean, Chinese, Asian, and South American Indian ancestry.

The cause of SLE remains unknown, although it is thought that genetic, hormonal, immune and environmental factors have a role. The reasons that support this are:

• Relatives of patients with SLE are at increased risk of developing the disease.
• The disease is more often seen in both of a pair of identical twins than it is in fraternal (non-identical) twins.
• Prevalence of the disease in certain races also implies a genetic (inherited) influence in the occurrence of SLE.
• Evidence for hormonal abnormalities is based primarily on the observation that SLE is much more common among women in their childbearing years.

Many abnormalities of the immune system occur in patients with SLE. The reason for this remains unclear and it is not known which are primary and which are secondary causes. These abnormalities in immune regulation are thought to result from loss of "self" (substances belonging to the body) tolerance. This means that SLE patients are no longer totally tolerant of all their self-antigens and consequently an immune response develops to these antigens.

Chinese Medicine

Click here to see the causes of SLE from a TCM perspective
From the traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) viewpoint, the major cause of SLE is an inborn insufficiency that disturbs the balance of yin and yang. SLE may be acquired when environmental pathogens (dryness, dampness, cold, summer-heat, wind and fire evils) affect this balance. Inborn insufficiencies or acquired disorders also lead to depletion of vital energy (qi) and yin fluid. This can cause impaired functioning of the body and a defect in resistance to illness.

Ancient TCM classics like the Jinkui Yaolue (Summary from the Golden Chest) refer to diseases that poison the yin-yang balance. Constitutional or bodily weakness enables environmental pathogens to invade the body. This disturbs the harmonious balance of yin and yang and illness results. As an example, over-exposure to sunlight, considered to be a heat evil, causes the accumulation of heat and toxic pathogens in the body, and this in turn triggers organ system damage. Diseases where yang is dominant in the body present with yang-type symptoms, such as flushing of the face, high fever, dislike of heat, dark-colored urine or constipation. Diseases dominated by yin present with yin-type symptoms, such as pallor, cold limbs, an aversion to cold, pale urine or watery stools.

Parallels can be made with Western medicine's understanding of SLE. For example, SLE is a result of the malfunction of the body's immune system, which in TCM can be interpreted as a yin and yang imbalance. Genetic and environmental factors are also known to play a role in the development of SLE. It has been suggested that a virus may be partially responsible for its cause. This thinking is in line with the TCM concepts of environmental pathogens and an inborn deficiency being linked to the occurrence of SLE.

Western Medicine

The onset of SLE can be highly variable, as can be the progression of the disease. Early symptoms may be non-specific and include muscular pain, nausea, vomiting, headaches, depression and easy bruising. Sometimes symptoms are more specific and more than one may be present. Symptoms may be mild or severe, fleeting or persistent.
General symptoms

• Fatigue occurs in virtually all patients with SLE and may be experienced with the onset of SLE or only with a relapse of the disorder.
• Swelling of the ankles is common.
• There is often a gain or loss in body-weight.
• Low-grade fever is seen in 80 per cent of patients.
• It is usually an episodic disease (occurs from time to time).

Skin and mucous membranes
The skin is affected in over 70 per cent of cases. Often, rashes occur after exposure to ultraviolet light and such exposure may lead to major flares involving other organ systems as well. Abnormal sensitivity to sunlight is experienced by about half of all patients with SLE and is more common in those who are fair and light-skinned.

Typical ''butterfly" distribution facial rash seen in SLE.

A classical characteristic of SLE is the "butterfly" rash that occurs across the face. Hair-loss is also common. Mouth ulcers occur frequently in active disease, but they may be relatively painless. A painful throat may accompany a flare.

Vascular system (blood vessels)
A disorder of the vascular system known as Raynaud's phenomenon occurs in 20 to 30 per cent of patients. Classically, the fingers turn white followed by a bluish cyanotic hue, finally replaced by a red flush as dilatation of the blood vessels occurs. The full three-color change does not always happen, but excessive sensitivity of the hands to the cold is common.
Musculoskeletal system
Painful and arthritic joints are the most common symptoms of SLE and experienced by almost all patients. Symptoms can occur in any joint and often clear up in one to three days. Fingers, hands wrists and knees are the most commonly affected. Less frequently, ankles, elbows, shoulders and hips are involved. Stiffness on waking can last several minutes.
Renal system
In 50 per cent of SLE patients, the kidneys become involved. There may be rapid onset of an acute and painful kidney inflammation or traces of blood or protein may be found on analysis of the urine. Urinary tract infections are common.
Nervous system
Nervous disorders occur in virtually all SLE patients. Anxiety and/or depression are common in response to the illness and the threat of loss of health, family and job. The prospect of disability and dependency can be very distressing.
Symptoms may include insomnia, loss of appetite, constipation, palpitations, diarrhea, over-breathing, memory loss, emotional instability, confusion and decreased concentration. Seizures (convulsions) occur in more than 10 per cent of patients. The incidence of stroke, with resulting abnormalities of sensation and power, is similar.
Headaches are a frequent complaint and are usually due to stress and tension. Migraine occurs in 20 per cent of patients.
Cardiorespiratory system
Chest pain, cough and breathlessness occur frequently. These result from a variety of processes involving the lungs, the lining of the chest wall and diaphragm. Pain on breathing is commonly experienced and is often accompanied by chest discomfort. It may be worsened by lying down.
Gastrointestinal tract
Involvement of the gastrointestinal tract is common. Up to 25 per cent of patients have esophageal complaints, including difficulty swallowing. Indigestion, abdominal pain, nausea and vomiting are also common.
Blood
Anemia occurs in at least 50 per cent of patients. On laboratory analysis, abnormalities in the blood cells and clotting mechanisms are commonly found.

Chinese Medicine

TCM practitioners will examine the sufferer and categorize the symptoms under special syndrome groups known as "disharmony patterns." Certain disharmony patterns are present during different stages of the disease. The presentation of SLE is often complicated, but some common patterns can be classified:

Excessive toxic heat accumulation

Individuals present with persistent high-grade fevers, the appearance of a rash on the face or other areas, joint pain, muscle soreness or pain, fatigue, thirst and a desire for cold drinks. Irritability, insomnia, constipation and production of dark-colored, scanty urine are also common.
In severe cases, loss of consciousness, delirium, muscle spasms, bruising or petechiae (small, flat blood spots under the skin), the spitting up of blood and the presence of blood in the urine or stool may also occur. Exposure to sunlight and the ingestion of certain foods or drugs are factors that can exacerbate the disease and induce flare-ups.

Blood yin deficiency

In this deficiency there is a persistent low-grade fever, a hot sensation in the chest, palms and soles of the feet, irritability, fatigue and a reluctance to speak. There is general swelling of tissues, redness of the face, spontaneous perspiration and night sweats, and loin and joint pain.

Toxic factor attacking the heart

Symptoms include palpitations, shortness of breath, chest fullness with a feeling of oppression and local heat, spontaneous perspiration, pallor and cold limbs.

Kidney yin deficiency

Individuals usually experience pain in the back, legs and feet, limb weakness and a sensation of hotness in the face. In more serious cases, sores appear in the mouth and on the tongue, hot sensations are felt in the chest, palms and soles of the feet, and the individual feels emotionless. Sometimes low-grade fever and swelling may be present.

Impairment of the liver due to heat

In this disharmony pattern, pain in the upper sides of the abdomen, abdominal distension, irregular and painful menstruation in females, skin rashes, bruising, insomnia, dizziness and loss of appetite are commonly experienced.

Western Medicine

The diagnosis of systemic lupus erythematosus can be difficult. The disease may present in many different ways and most of the laboratory tests carried out on patients with SLE are not specific. For these reasons, other diseases have to be carefully considered before a diagnosis of SLE can be made. Physicians should always consider the possibility of SLE in a disease which is affecting many systems of the body, especially those involving the skin and joints of young women.
In 1982, the American College of Rheumatology compiled a list of 11 criteria, at least four of which should be present, not necessarily at the same time, to make a diagnosis of SLE. In some patients, only one or two criteria may be present initially and after several weeks, months or even years do the others appear. These criteria are:

• Characteristic "butterfly" rash on the face
• Generalized skin rash
• Mouth ulcers
• Arthritis
• Sensitivity to ultraviolet light
• Inflammation of the lining of the chest wall or the membrane surrounding the heart
• Renal (kidney) disorder
• Nervous system disorder
• Low red or white blood cell count
• Positive antinuclear antibodies
• Positive lupus anticoagulant

These last two are immunologic laboratory tests.

Chinese Medicine

Diagnosis in TCM places importance on determining the circumstances and manifestations of a disease through inquiry and symptom observation. Diagnosis is based on the traditional four examination techniques:

• Questioning: The TCM practitioner will establish the medical history of both the patient and his family.
• Observation: Examination of the physical features of the body, such as the face, tongue, hair, nails, sputum (mucus that is coughed up), and location of pain, all offer clues to the problem. The tongue is a particularly useful indicator of the functioning of the internal organs.
• Listening and swelling: The smelling of sputum and breath and listening to the sounds produced by the chest offer additional clues to the patient's health.
• Touching: Feeling the pulse is a cornerstone of TCM diagnosis and gives the practitioner much information about any bodily imbalance.

In SLE, the disharmony patterns present at different stages during the course of the disease and can be described as follows: :

Excessive toxic heat accumulation

In TCM, it is held that the occurrence of SLE is closely related to over-heating of the heart meridian. The heart controls the blood and blood vessels. When the heart pumps, blood is transported within the vessels around the entire body. The heart, blood and blood vessels are thus united by their common activities. When heat pathogens are congested in the heart meridian, it means a serious invasion of the internal organs has occurred. The qi and blood bring these pathogens to every part of the body, damaging internal organs, muscles and skin along the way.
On examination, the tongue appears red or dark red and ulcerated, or sores may be present on the inside of the mouth. The tongue may be coated with a fur that is greasy and yellow, dry and yellow, greasy and white, or the fur may be absent altogether. The pulse feels taut and rapid.

Example of greasy and yellow tongue fur

Blood yin deficiency

When the body accumulates too many heat pathogens over a period of time, the body fluids dry up and organs will not function properly. This decreases the production of blood and kidney essence and leads to a morbid condition of general weakness with sweating, low-grade fevers and hot sensations in the palms and soles of the feet.
On examination, the tongue appears red with a white fur coating or with no coating. The pulse sign feels thready, rapid and weak.

Toxic factor attacking the heart

Impairment of the functioning of several internal organs signals involvement of the heart and a serious effect to the blood flow. Individuals present with pallor, palpitations and cold extremities.
On examination, the tongue is pale and coated with thin white fur. The pulse feels thready, weak, or choppy.

Kidney yin deficiency

This occurs usually in a late stage of the disease when the pathogens finally invade the kidney. Kidney-yin refers to the fluid and essence stored in the kidneys. The invading pathogens cause a deficiency in the amount of this fluid and essence and the kidneys begin to over-function. This is the yang part of the kidney compensating for the loss of yin and creates a virtual fire in the kidneys. This produces back pain, limb weakness and heat symptoms such as fever or tongue sores.
On examination, the tongue appears bulky, moist and pale. The tip of the tongue may also be red. The pulse feels deep, thready and weak.

Impairment of the liver due to heat

Heat pathogens dry up body fluid and this leads to inadequate nourishment for the liver. In TCM thinking, the liver helps regulate qi and blood movement, and the digestive function of the spleen. Individuals with this disharmony pattern present with pain in the liver region, bleeding problems or loss of appetite.
On examination, an enlarged liver and spleen may be palpable.

Western Medicine

The management of SLE should be comprehensive and include drug and non-drug treatment. Therapy is individualized for each patient depending on the manifestations of disease and their severity.

Corticosteroids
Systemic corticosteroid therapy is the mainstay of treatment in SLE. However, not all patients require steroids, and steroids can do more harm than good. When needed, oral maintenance doses of prednisone or prednisolone are usually prescribed.

Severe symptoms affecting the whole body, such as sustained high fevers and severe blood disorders, often need to be treated with higher doses of corticosteroids. Involvement of organs such as the heart, lungs, and central nervous system also usually requires treatment with corticosteroids.

A topical steroid is usually prescribed for skin rashes.

NSAIDs
Mild symptoms of arthritis and muscular pain are usually managed with non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), such as indomethacin, naproxen and ketoprofen. More severe symptoms may need an antimalarial agent and occasionally low doses of corticosteroids may be required.

Antimalarials
The antimalarials chloroquine and hydroxychloroquine possess anti-inflammatory properties and have been found of benefit in treating inflammatory conditions which have an immunologic basis. They are usually used when other first-line therapies (such as NSAIDs) fail. They are prescribed for more severe skin and joint manifestations of SLE.

Immunosuppressants
As long-term corticosteroid therapy, particularly at the higher doses, tends to cause side-effects, immunosuppressants such as azothiaprine, cyclophosphamide and methotrexate are sometimes added in an attempt to lower the dose of corticosteriod required. These drugs suppress the immune response. As immunosuppressants themselves pose a risk of long-term toxicity they need to used with care, but can be useful in the treatment of acute and severe organ involvement.

Psychiatric support
The threat of a chronic disease can be very stressful. Visiting a doctor frequently and having many laboratory tests with long waits for the results can be an emotional burden.Emotional support in the treatment of SLE is essential. It is also important that patients have extensive rest.

Preventive measures
All possible means to prevent provocation or exacerbation of SLE should be undertaken. (See Prevention section.)

As SLE is an episodic disease and is characterized by exacerbation and remission, it is extremely important to withdraw therapy slowly when an exacerbation has quieted down. This avoids unnecessary drug toxicity.

Patients with SLE need a to see their doctors at least once every three to six months, even if the disease is inactive. Patients with active disease must be assessed more frequently.

Chinese Medicine

Treatment of SLE from a TCM perspective will depend on the symptoms of the individual patient. In addition to herbal decoctions used to alleviate disharmony pattern symptoms, treatment may include acupuncture for relieving pain and stiffness in the joints, and qi-gong to help focus the energy of the body in fighting the disease and strengthening the mind.

Examples of decoctions used for the different disharmony patterns

Excessive toxic heat accumulation

Therapeutic aim:To clear away heat and toxins, cool down the blood, protect theyin, remove obstructions in themeridians and clear up rashes.

Prescription: Qingying decoction

shi gao	gypsum
shu di huang	processed rehmannia root
mai dong	dwarf lilyturf tuber
zhi mu	common anemarrhena root
niu xi	achyranthes root

For individuals with high fever, poor concentration and delirium, the dosages of heat-clearing drugs should be increased or the following added:

shang shi gao	unprocessed gypsum
huang lian	golden thread
da huang	rhubarb

Some patent Chinese medicines likePurple Snowy Pill, Bezoar Bolus for Resurrection and Treasured Bolus can be taken at the same time.

Yin blood deficiency

Therapeutic aim:To replenish the yin, nourish and cool down the blood, and eliminate toxins.

Prescription: Modified Zhibai Dihuang pill

zhi mu	common anemarrhena root
huang bai	amur cork-tree
shu di	processed rhemannia root
shan yu rou	Asiatic cornelian cherry fruit
shan yao	common yam root
ze xie	oriental water-plantain root
dan pi	tree peony bark
fu ling	Indian bread

For individuals with spleen deficiency add:

bai zhi	large head atractylodes root
chen pi	dried tangerine peel
fu ling	Indian bread

In cases of very high fever add:

yin hua

honeysuckle flower

For dizziness add:

ju hua	chrysanthemum flower
chuan xiong	Szechwan lovage root

 

Toxic factor attacking the heart

Therapeutic aim:To nourish the yin, replenish the qi, calm the mind, and clear away heat and toxins.

Prescription: Modified Huanglian antidote decoction

huang lian	golden thread
huang qin	baical skullcap root
huang bai	amur cork tree
zhi zi	Cape jasmine fruit

For spleen deficiency add:

dang shen	pilose asiabell root
bai zhi	large head atractylodes root

 

For individuals with a feeling of chest fullness add:

hou po	magnolia bark
su geng	perilla stem

For yin deficiency add:

yu zhu	fragrant Solomon's seal rhizome
huang jing	agastache or Solomon's seed
dong chong xia cao	Chinese caterpillar fungus

 

Kidney yin deficiency

Therapeutic aim:To nourish the yin, tonify the kidneys, activate the blood circulation and eliminate toxins.

Prescription: Modified Siwu decoction

dang gui	Chinese angelica
chuan xiong	Szechwan lovage root
shu di	processed rehmannia root
bai shao	white peony root

For dampness-heat symptoms in the lower burner add:

che qian zi	plantain seed
Bi xie	long yam
qu mai	Chinese pink herb

For individuals with backache add:

tu si zi	dodder seed
chuan duan	Himalayan teasel root

For joint pain add:

ji xue teng	suberect spatholobus stem
shen jin cao	common club-moss herb
liu ji nu	diverse wormwood herb
xu chang qing	paniculated swallow-wort root

 

Impairment of the liver due to heat

Therapeutic aim:To nourish the yin, cool down the blood, eliminate toxins, activate the blood circulation, clear away blood stasis and remove obstructions in the meridians.

Prescription: Modified Xiefu Zhuyu decoction

tao ren	peach seed
hong hua	safflower flower
dang gui	Chinese angelica
sheng di	common yam root
chuan xiong	Szechwan lovage root
chia hao	red peony root
niu xi	achyranthes root
jie geng	platycodon root
chai hu	Chinese tororwax root
zhi qiao	orange fruit
gan cao	liquorice root

For individuals with severe blood stasis add:

san leng	bur-reed tuber
e zhu	zedoary rhizome
yi mu cao	motherwort herb
chuan xin lian	andrographis herb
gui jian yu	winged spindle tree

For severe abdominal distention and pain below the ribs add:

hou po	magnolia bark
chen pi	dried tangerine peel
xiang fu	nut-grass

 

For qi deficiency and residual heat toxins add:

huang qi	milk-vetch root
qin jiao	large-leafed gentian
wu she	black snake

For over heated blood and a well-defined rash add:

ji guan hua	cockscomb
mei gui hua	rose
ling xiao hua	trumpet creeper flower

Western Medicine

No specific measures are available to prevent the development of SLE. However some measures may help prevent flare-ups or exacerbation.

Sensitivity to sunlight may provoke disease. Photosensitive patients should use sunscreens daily with a SPF of at least 15. For those who are very photosensitive, sunscreen should be used twice daily and protective measures taken to avoid exposure of the arms and face.

Patients with a history of drug-induced lupus should avoid the offending agent. Sulfonamides, penicillin and high-estrogen birth control pills, which may exacerbate SLE, should not be taken.

Exercise has been shown to lesson the fatigue associated with SLE.

In general, patients are not now dissuaded from pregnancy. However, in the presence of active disease, specifically active renal disease, childbearing should be postponed. SLE sufferers should be aware of the possibility of a flare-up during pregnancy.

In postmenopausal women, estrogen is recommended for its benefit regarding osteoporosis and coronary artery disease, unless there are contraindications or the SLE relapses.

Immunization against influenza and pneumonia is advisable.

Dietary precautions may be helpful. They include avoiding salt and oil, and certain vegetables, such as celery, parsnip, parsley and coriander, which are rich in light-sensitive psoralens and can increase the risk of photosensitivity.

Avoid foods containing light-sensitive psoralens, eg celery.

Chinese Medicine

Precautions should be taken to help prevent attacks or exacerbation of SLE.

Reduce the risk of invasion by exogenous pathogens by wearing clothing that is appropriate for the weather conditions and by avoiding dampness and over-exposure to sunlight.

Avoid over-exertion, but engage in moderate exercise to strengthen the body's constitution. Tai chi is one form of exercise that may beneficial. Consult both your Western doctor and TCM practitioner about an exercise program that is right for you.

Maintain a stable emotional and mental state. SLE is a chronic disease that can cause depression and problems of concentration. Tai chi and qi-gong may help to focus the mind and avoid depression. The support of family and friends should be encouraged to help maintain a positive outlook.

Tai chi

Avoid drugs that are known to exacerbate SLE. (Consult your Western doctor for a list of these.) Prepackaged Chinese medicines that contain cinnabar, mercury or lead can precipitate an exacerbation of SLE. Foods such as seafood, shellfish or milk may do likewise. It is important to discuss with your Western doctor and TCM practitioner which foods and drugs to avoid.

Western Medicine

Chinese Medicine